Rigid protection
A tube resists some external loads better, but performance depends on its body, ends and interior. Check that rods fit without pressure on tips and guides. Padding and retainers help if they actually secure tackle rather than merely appearing in a description.
Soft cases
A soft case is often convenient for weight and packing, but does not replace rigid protection against crushing. Semi-rigid versions differ too. Decide whether you need separate compartments, space for fitted reels and pockets; dense fabric does not make the entire item waterproof.
Try before buying
Measure your longest rod’s packed length and allow for guide protectors if used. Neither an enormous empty tube nor a zip stretched around a rod is desirable. Check seams, handles, shoulder strap and fastenings. Do not load heavy objects onto tackle or leave hooks loose in pockets during transport.